India Moves to Block Proton Mail Amid Privacy Clash and Offensive Content Allegations
Court order in Karnataka raises questions about data privacy, user protections, and India’s tech regulatory future
Indian Court Orders Immediate Action Against Proton Mail
In a decisive move that intensifies the debate around digital privacy and state surveillance, the High Court of Karnataka has directed the Indian government to block Proton Mail, a widely used encrypted email service, for refusing to provide user data.
Issued during an April 29 hearing, Justice M. Nagaprasanna ordered a “forthwith” domain block of Proton Mail under the Information Technology Act of 2008, following a complaint by a New Delhi-based design firm. The firm alleges that its employees received offensive emails routed through the platform.
“There must be consequences when technology platforms refuse to cooperate with law enforcement,” an unnamed official stated in response to the order.
A Global Tug-of-War Between Privacy and Regulation
While it remains to be seen whether the order will be implemented or challenged, the case is far from isolated. In March 2024, Proton reported that Indian authorities threatened a similar ban, allegedly linked to hoax bomb threats sent via the service. However, the platform remained accessible.
This move follows a global crackdown on privacy-first platforms. In France, Telegram founder Pavel Durov was arrested over his platform’s failure to moderate illegal content. In Spain, Proton AG, the Swiss company behind Proton Mail, disclosed user data to authorities earlier this year — sparking fierce backlash from privacy advocates.
“This is part of a global trend,” said a cybersecurity researcher based in Bengaluru. “Governments are trying to pierce digital anonymity in the name of national security.”
India’s Regulatory Climate for Crypto and Tech Firms
India’s regulatory posture is increasingly stringent toward digital platforms, especially as it vies to govern a market of over 1.4 billion people, including 100 million+ digital asset holders.
In parallel to the Proton Mail case, cryptocurrency exchanges and privacy-centric services have faced mounting restrictions. Notably, users in India now pay a 30% tax on crypto profits, enforced since April 2022. Meanwhile, international platforms like Tornado Cash and dozens of exchanges have faced bans in South Korea and the U.S., showing that privacy-focused platforms face pressure across jurisdictions.
Is Privacy Under Siege in India?
For Proton Mail, which has built its reputation on end-to-end encryption and user privacy, this legal standoff raises serious questions. Can such platforms survive in markets where compliance demands transparency? Or will this signal a chilling effect on platforms reluctant to compromise user data?
Cointelegraph reached out to Proton AG but received no response at the time of publication.
Share This
