OpenAI’s Worldcoin Stirs Privacy Debate as U.S. Launch Sparks Legal Uncertainty
Iris-Scanning Crypto Project Faces Resistance Amid Patchwork State Laws and Global Bans
Worldcoin, the biometric identity and crypto initiative backed by OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, is triggering alarm bells across the United States as it prepares for rollout in six major cities. The company’s plan to scan irises in exchange for cryptocurrency has reignited global privacy concerns, especially in a country where data protection laws vary drastically by state.
Privacy Advocates Sound the Alarm
While Altman positions World as a safeguard of digital identity in an AI-dominated age, privacy experts are skeptical.
“World is the opposite of privacy. It’s a trap,” said Nick Almond, CEO of FactoryDAO, in a post on X.
The project, formerly known as Worldcoin, offers users a crypto reward in exchange for their biometric data. The method: a metallic orb scans users’ irises to create a unique digital identity, known as a “World ID.”
This system is already banned in Spain, Hong Kong, and Brazil, and under investigation in at least seven other countries including India, Italy, Colombia, and Kenya. The move into the U.S. is shaping up to be Altman’s most legally complex expansion yet.
Legal Vacuum in U.S. Raises Risks
On April 30, Altman confirmed that World will operate in Atlanta, Austin, Los Angeles, Miami, Nashville, and San Francisco—locations dubbed “key innovation hubs.”
But there’s a problem: the U.S. lacks a comprehensive federal law governing biometric data. Regulation depends heavily on state law, and only California and Texas—two of the rollout states—have biometric legislation in place.
In Texas, even that protection may be limited.
“The effectiveness of user data protections hinges almost entirely on the Texas Attorney General’s priorities,” said Andrew Rossow, a cyber and public affairs lawyer.
This uneven legal landscape means residents in Georgia, Florida, and Tennessee have no state-level biometric protections, relying solely on general federal rules that demand transparency but set no specific safeguards.
Global Pressure and Regulatory Pushback Mount
Internationally, Worldcoin’s data collection practices have been challenged in courts and by regulators.
In Spain, authorities allege that minors were scanned without consent, and that users were not provided proper withdrawal options. Brazil cited “irreversible data capture” and the potential for exploiting poor communities with crypto incentives before issuing an outright ban in January 2025.
In response to mounting criticism, Privacy International warned that biometric tools like World could be used for “profiling, discrimination, and mass surveillance.” Amnesty International added that these tools often rely on flawed science and even echo eugenicist principles.
Ethereum Researchers Defend the Tech
Not all observers are concerned. Tomasz Stańczak, co-executive director of the Ethereum Foundation, said he spent over 100 hours reviewing World’s architecture and believes the privacy protections are solid. Others like Paul Dylan-Ennis, a researcher and academic, admitted that while the tech may be secure, the project gives off an unsettling, “Black Mirror” aesthetic.
Worldcoin’s Bet on Dating and Digital Integration
Despite controversy, World is finding opportunities. In Japan, dating app Tinder is testing integration with World’s ID system. This could give users a “privacy-first way to prove they’re real humans,” according to Match Group CEO Spencer Rascoff.
In the U.S., Tinder has 7.8 million active users. A partnership here could catapult World into a commanding share of the American online dating market. Expanding to other platforms like Bumble and Hinge could see World controlling up to 67% of U.S. dating app identities, aggregating personal data from tens of millions.
But the $1.4 billion fine against Google in Texas for unauthorized data tracking stands as a cautionary tale. With Illinois and New York also ramping up lawsuits against biometrics firms, World’s path forward is anything but smooth.
Share This
